QUINIX Sport News: 2025 Fantasy Baseball Week 4 Trade Values: Tyler Soderstrom surging but elite status remains uncertain

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Pocket
WhatsApp

The trade values chart aims to help you make the best value trades you can

​ 

tyler-soderstrom.jpg

When is a hot start just a hot start? When is it something more? That’s one of the toughest questions Fantasy Baseball players face at this point in the year because answering it correctly could make a huge difference in how the rest of your season goes.

Let’s take Tyler Soderstrom as an example. He’s been one of the very best hitters in the league this season, ranking as the No. 1 first baseman in Fantasy and a top-five hitter overall, and he’s doing so after being largely an afterthought in most drafts. His 281.1 ADP coming into the season means he was drafted in most 12-team leagues, but certainly not all of them. In CBS Fantasy leagues, Soderstrom was just 45% rostered to open the season, and he looked more like a fringe corner infield option with some upside, but not a potential superstar. 

But he’s hitting like a superstar right now for sure. Through his first 19 games, Soderstrom’s .468 wOBA is backed up by a .439 xwOBA, the 10th-best mark in baseball, sandwiched between Kyle Schwarber and Kyle Tucker. That’s elite company, and he’s earned his production so far, ranking in the 87th percentile or better in average exit velocity, barrel rate, expected batting average, and expected slugging percentage. And he’s doing it with really strong plate discipline, striking out in just 18.4% of his trips to the plate.

Which is to say, if Soderstrom were breaking out, this is exactly what he’d look like. He flashed plus power and a good approach at the plate last season, and was a prospect of some renown before that, peaking as the No. 21 prospect in Baseball America’s 2022 preseason ranking. This isn’t entirely out of nowhere. 

But it’s probably not entirely real, either. Soderstrom is probably just hot in the traditional meaning of the word. Locked in. On a heater. Whatever term you want to use for it, that’s probably what we’re seeing in the early going, especially since Soderstrom has had just 16.5% of his plate appearances come against left-handed pitching so far; Matt Olson, who played every day last season, had 27.3% of his PA come against lefties, just to establish a baseline. 

That’s not to say Soderstrom is going to fall apart whenever he starts facing more lefties, but it’s one reason to expect his hot start to slow down eventually. The other, biggest reason to expect him to slow down: Plain old regression. 

We see it every season, and we have to be reminded every season that hot April doesn’t necessarily mean a player will be a dominant force all season long. At this same point in 2024, Ryan O’Hearn, Tyler O’Neill, Michael Busch, LaMonte Wade, Jess Winker, Gavin Sheets, and Jake Cronenworth were all in the top-20 among hitters with at least 50 PA in expected wOBA, for example, and none of them kept that pace up. 

A bunch of those guys had long track records that made it easier to see they wouldn’t keep it up, of course, but Busch is an instructive case. Like Soderstrom, Busch was a young, recent top prospect who was hitting the cover off the ball for the first few weeks, and while he did have a breakout season, he wasn’t exactly a must-start player the rest of the way – from April 20 on, Busch hit .239/.326/.408. His hot start wasn’t fake in that he was hitting the ball well enough to earn his production, but it did turn out to be a fluke, despite the good underlying numbers. 

That’s not to say the same is true of Soderstrom. But if you’re out there looking to make a trade involving him, it’s worth keeping in mind that while he might be a must-start player the rest of the way, it probably isn’t the likeliest outcome. I’ve moved him way up in my rest-of-season trade values, but I bet there will be some grumbling among you that I still have the likes of Triston Casas, Vinnie Pasquantino, and Christian Walker ahead of him. 

Maybe I’ll end up wrong, and Soderstrom will go on to hit 35 homers and establish himself as one of the elite options at the position for the next half-decade or so. It’s certainly within the realm of possibility. But I’m not ready to rank him that way, hot start or not. 

H2H Trade Values Chart

Ranking Player Value Eligible
1 Aaron Judge 46 DH-OF
2 Shohei Ohtani 46 DH-SP
3 Bobby Witt 45 SS
4 Jose Ramirez 41 3B-DH
5 Juan Soto 41 OF
6 Kyle Tucker 40 OF
7 Yordan Alvarez 37 DH-OF
8 Corbin Carroll 37 OF
9 Francisco Lindor 37 SS
10 Gunnar Henderson 35 SS
11 Elly De La Cruz 32 SS
12 Mookie Betts 30 OF-SS
13 Vladimir Guerrero 30 1B-DH
14 Fernando Tatis 28 OF
15 Bryce Harper 26 1B
16 Ketel Marte 26 2B-DH
17 Julio Rodriguez 25 OF
18 Jarren Duran 25 OF
19 Tarik Skubal 25 SP
20 Zack Wheeler 25 SP
21 Jackson Chourio 25 OF
22 Paul Skenes 25 SP
23 Austin Riley 24 3B
24 Matt Olson 24 1B
25 Freddie Freeman 24 1B
26 Corey Seager 23 SS
27 Manny Machado 23 3B-DH
28 William Contreras 23 C-DH
29 Jackson Merrill 22 OF
30 Trea Turner 21 SS
31 Jose Altuve 21 2B-OF
32 Jazz Chisholm 21 2B-3B-OF
33 Logan Gilbert 21 SP
34 Ronald Acuna 21 OF
35 Rafael Devers 21 3B-DH
36 Cole Ragans 21 SP
37 Garrett Crochet 20 SP
38 Corbin Burnes 20 SP
39 Chris Sale 20 SP
40 Dylan Cease 20 SP
41 Marcell Ozuna 20 DH
42 Kyle Schwarber 20 DH
43 Brent Rooker 20 DH
44 Michael King 19 SP
45 Ozzie Albies 19 2B
46 Pete Alonso 19 1B
47 Blake Snell 18 SP
48 James Wood 18 OF
49 Teoscar Hernandez 17 OF
50 Framber Valdez 17 SP
51 Hunter Greene 17 SP
52 Max Fried 17 SP
53 Spencer Schwellenbach 17 SP
54 Logan Webb 17 SP
55 Adley Rutschman 16 C-DH
56 Jacob deGrom 16 SP
57 Emmanuel Clase 16 RP
58 Shota Imanaga 16 SP
59 Seiya Suzuki 16 DH-OF
60 Alex Bregman 16 3B
61 Edwin Diaz 16 RP
62 Yoshinobu Yamamoto 16 SP
63 Spencer Strider 16 SP
64 Aaron Nola 16 SP
65 Devin Williams 16 RP
66 Freddy Peralta 16 SP
67 Hunter Brown 16 SP
68 Joe Ryan 16 SP
69 Luis Castillo 16 SP
70 Lawrence Butler 15 OF
71 Wyatt Langford 15 DH-OF
72 Pablo Lopez 15 SP
73 Josh Hader 15 RP
74 Kris Bubic 15 RP
75 Zac Gallen 15 SP
76 Michael Harris 15 OF
77 Christian Yelich 15 DH-OF
78 Mason Miller 15 RP
79 Willy Adames 15 SS
80 Josh Naylor 15 1B
81 Christian Walker 15 1B
82 Riley Greene 15 DH-OF
83 Marcus Semien 15 2B
84 Jordan Westburg 15 2B-3B
85 Anthony Santander 15 DH-OF
86 George Kirby 15 SP
87 Junior Caminero 15 3B
88 Tyler Glasnow 15 SP
89 Bryce Miller 15 SP
90 Triston Casas 15 1B
91 Oneil Cruz 15 OF-SS
92 Bryan Reynolds 15 DH-OF
93 Cristopher Sanchez 15 SP
94 Bailey Ober 15 SP
95 Salvador Perez 15 1B-C-DH
96 Andres Munoz 15 RP
97 Raisel Iglesias 15 RP
98 Bo Bichette 15 SS
99 Brandon Nimmo 15 OF
100 Vinnie Pasquantino 15 1B-DH
101 Sandy Alcantara 15 SP
102 Ryan Helsley 15 RP
103 Mike Trout 15 OF
104 Cody Bellinger 15 1B-DH-OF
105 Carlos Rodon 15 SP
106 Jack Flaherty 15 SP
107 Will Smith 15 C
108 Ian Happ 15 OF
109 Bryan Woo 15 SP
110 Tanner Bibee 15 SP
111 Steven Kwan 15 OF
112 Robbie Ray 15 SP
113 Yusei Kikuchi 15 SP
114 Mark Vientos 15 3B
115 Randy Arozarena 15 OF
116 Luis Robert 15 OF
117 Seth Lugo 15 SP
118 Matt McLain 15 2B-SS
119 C.J. Abrams 15 SS
120 Cal Raleigh 15 C-DH
121 Willson Contreras 15 1B-C-DH
122 J.T. Realmuto 14 C
123 Adolis Garcia 14 DH-OF
124 Yainer Diaz 14 C-DH
125 Pete Crow-Armstrong 14 OF
126 Isaac Paredes 14 3B
127 Eugenio Suarez 14 3B
128 Matt Chapman 14 3B
129 Jeff Hoffman 14 RP
130 Jack Leiter 14 SP
131 Roki Sasaki 14 SP
132 Jasson Dominguez 14 OF
133 Dylan Crews 14 OF
134 Ryan Walker 14 RP
135 Tommy Edman 13 2B-OF
136 Zach Eflin 13 SP
137 Jung Hoo Lee 12 OF
138 Tyler O’Neill 12 OF
139 Nathan Eovaldi 11 SP
140 Tanner Houck 11 SP
141 Tyler Soderstrom 10 1B
142 Paul Goldschmidt 9 1B
143 Royce Lewis 9 3B-DH
144 Xander Bogaerts 8 2B-SS
145 Alec Bohm 8 3B
146 Shane Baz 8 SP
147 Ryan Pepiot 8 SP
148 Jake Burger 8 1B-3B-DH
149 Nick Castellanos 8 OF
150 Brenton Doyle 8 OF
151 Dansby Swanson 8 SS
152 Lars Nootbaar 8 OF
153 Taylor Ward 8 OF
154 Sonny Gray 8 SP
155 Kristian Campbell 8 2B
156 Nick Lodolo 8 SP
157 Jhoan Duran 8 RP
158 Robert Suarez 7 RP
159 Bowden Francis 7 RP-SP
160 Xavier Edwards 7 SS
161 Carlos Correa 7 SS
162 Nico Hoerner 7 2B
163 Anthony Volpe 6 SS
164 Ezequiel Tovar 6 SS
165 Trevor Megill 6 RP
166 Zachary Neto 6 SS
167 Gavin Williams 5 SP
168 Spencer Torkelson 5 1B
169 Luis Arraez 5 1B-2B-DH
170 Nick Pivetta 5 SP
171 Felix Bautista 5 RP
172 Clay Holmes 5 RP
173 Shea Langeliers 5 C
174 Brandon Lowe 5 2B-DH
175 Justin Verlander 5 SP
176 Jackson Holliday 5 2B-SS
177 Jonathan India 5 2B-3B-OF
178 Nolan Arenado 5 3B
179 Luis Rengifo 5 2B-3B
180 Grayson Rodriguez 5 SP
181 Max Muncy 5 3B
182 Andres Gimenez 5 2B
183 Jesus Luzardo 5 SP
184 Dennis Santana 5 RP
185 MacKenzie Gore 5 SP
186 Kyle Manzardo 4 DH
187 Kevin Gausman 4 SP
188 Cedric Mullins 4 OF
189 Bryson Stott 4 2B
190 Cam Smith 4 3B-OF
191 Taj Bradley 4 SP
192 Tyler Stephenson 4 C
193 Kodai Senga 3 SP
194 Max Meyer 3 SP
195 Grant Holmes 3 RP-SP
196 Jeffrey Springs 3 SP
197 Logan O’Hoppe 3 C
198 Masyn Winn 3 SS
199 Jeremy Pena 3 SS
200 Spencer Steer 3 1B-DH-OF
201 Heliot Ramos 3 OF
202 Jose Berrios 3 SP
203 Brandon Pfaadt 3 SP
204 Brice Turang 3 2B
205 Luis Garcia 3 2B
206 Ben Rice 3 1B-DH
207 Yandy Diaz 3 1B-DH
208 Michael Conforto 3 DH-OF
209 Josh Jung 3 3B
210 Jose Alvarado 3 RP
211 Mitch Keller 3 SP
212 J.J. Bleday 3 OF
213 Trevor Story 3 SS
214 Victor Robles 3 OF
215 Ronel Blanco 3 SP
216 Michael Busch 3 1B
217 Christian Encarnacion-Strand 3 1B
218 Lane Thomas 3 OF
219 George Springer 3 DH-OF
220 Alec Burleson 3 1B-DH-OF
221 Byron Buxton 3 OF
222 Michael Toglia 3 1B
223 Clarke Schmidt 3 SP
224 Pete Fairbanks 3 RP
225 Jackson Jobe 3 RP

Roto Trade Values Chart

Ranking Player Value Eligible
1 Aaron Judge 48 DH-OF
2 Shohei Ohtani 48 DH-SP
3 Bobby Witt 48 SS
4 Jose Ramirez 40 3B-DH
5 Kyle Tucker 38 OF
6 Elly De La Cruz 37 SS
7 Fernando Tatis 34 OF
8 Corbin Carroll 34 OF
9 Juan Soto 33 OF
10 Julio Rodriguez 33 OF
11 Gunnar Henderson 33 SS
12 Francisco Lindor 33 SS
13 Yordan Alvarez 33 DH-OF
14 Vladimir Guerrero 30 1B-DH
15 Mookie Betts 30 OF-SS
16 Jarren Duran 29 OF
17 Jackson Chourio 29 OF
18 Bryce Harper 27 1B
19 Trea Turner 26 SS
20 Tarik Skubal 26 SP
21 Zack Wheeler 26 SP
22 Paul Skenes 26 SP
23 Jazz Chisholm 26 2B-3B-OF
24 Jackson Merrill 25 OF
25 Austin Riley 25 3B
26 Ronald Acuna 24 OF
27 Matt Olson 23 1B
28 Freddie Freeman 23 1B
29 William Contreras 23 C-DH
30 Corey Seager 23 SS
31 Manny Machado 23 3B-DH
32 Jose Altuve 23 2B-OF
33 Rafael Devers 23 3B-DH
34 Logan Gilbert 21 SP
35 Ozzie Albies 21 2B
36 Ketel Marte 21 2B-DH
37 Cole Ragans 21 SP
38 Marcell Ozuna 19 DH
39 Pete Alonso 19 1B
40 C.J. Abrams 18 SS
41 Michael Harris 18 OF
42 Oneil Cruz 18 OF-SS
43 Brent Rooker 18 DH
44 Kyle Schwarber 18 DH
45 Emmanuel Clase 17 RP
46 Chris Sale 15 SP
47 Garrett Crochet 15 SP
48 Corbin Burnes 15 SP
49 Dylan Cease 15 SP
50 Adley Rutschman 15 C-DH
51 Framber Valdez 15 SP
52 Michael King 15 SP
53 Yoshinobu Yamamoto 15 SP
54 James Wood 15 OF
55 Teoscar Hernandez 15 OF
56 Devin Williams 15 RP
57 Josh Hader 15 RP
58 Edwin Diaz 15 RP
59 Mason Miller 15 RP
60 Andres Munoz 15 RP
61 Raisel Iglesias 15 RP
62 Ryan Helsley 15 RP
63 Wyatt Langford 15 DH-OF
64 Jacob deGrom 15 SP
65 Max Fried 15 SP
66 Jordan Westburg 15 2B-3B
67 Marcus Semien 15 2B
68 Anthony Santander 15 DH-OF
69 Bo Bichette 15 SS
70 Hunter Greene 15 SP
71 Spencer Schwellenbach 15 SP
72 Spencer Strider 15 SP
73 Logan Webb 15 SP
74 Salvador Perez 15 1B-C-DH
75 Lawrence Butler 15 OF
76 Willy Adames 15 SS
77 Seiya Suzuki 15 DH-OF
78 Brenton Doyle 15 OF
79 Shota Imanaga 15 SP
80 Freddy Peralta 15 SP
81 Hunter Brown 15 SP
82 Joe Ryan 15 SP
83 Pablo Lopez 15 SP
84 Blake Snell 15 SP
85 Yainer Diaz 15 C-DH
86 Jeff Hoffman 15 RP
87 Jhoan Duran 15 RP
88 Bryce Miller 15 SP
89 Riley Greene 15 DH-OF
90 Josh Naylor 15 1B
91 Junior Caminero 15 3B
92 Zac Gallen 15 SP
93 Bryan Reynolds 15 DH-OF
94 Luis Robert 15 OF
95 Alex Bregman 15 3B
96 Christian Walker 15 1B
97 Triston Casas 15 1B
98 Tyler Glasnow 15 SP
99 Luis Castillo 15 SP
100 George Kirby 15 SP
101 Cristopher Sanchez 15 SP
102 Jack Flaherty 15 SP
103 Vinnie Pasquantino 15 1B-DH
104 Tanner Bibee 15 SP
105 Aaron Nola 15 SP
106 Cal Raleigh 15 C-DH
107 Willson Contreras 15 1B-C-DH
108 Bailey Ober 15 SP
109 Will Smith 15 C
110 Cody Bellinger 15 1B-DH-OF
111 Mike Trout 15 OF
112 Mark Vientos 15 3B
113 Christian Yelich 15 DH-OF
114 Randy Arozarena 15 OF
115 Sonny Gray 15 SP
116 Ian Happ 15 OF
117 Bryan Woo 15 SP
118 J.T. Realmuto 15 C
119 Robert Suarez 14 RP
120 Ryan Walker 14 RP
121 Matt McLain 14 2B-SS
122 Felix Bautista 14 RP
123 Sandy Alcantara 14 SP
124 Robbie Ray 14 SP
125 Tyler Soderstrom 14 1B
126 Kodai Senga 14 SP
127 Steven Kwan 14 OF
128 Jasson Dominguez 14 OF
129 Yusei Kikuchi 14 SP
130 Eugenio Suarez 13 3B
131 Matt Chapman 13 3B
132 Isaac Paredes 13 3B
133 Pete Crow-Armstrong 12 OF
134 Tommy Edman 11 2B-OF
135 Shea Langeliers 11 C
136 Jurickson Profar 10 OF
137 Dylan Crews 10 OF
138 Tanner Scott 9 RP
139 Trevor Megill 9 RP
140 Kristian Campbell 9 2B
141 Brice Turang 8 2B
142 Xavier Edwards 8 SS
143 Carlos Rodon 7 SP
144 Shane Baz 7 SP
145 Seth Lugo 7 SP
146 Luis Garcia 7 2B
147 Xander Bogaerts 7 2B-SS
148 Nick Castellanos 7 OF
149 Adolis Garcia 7 DH-OF
150 Dansby Swanson 7 SS
151 Spencer Steer 7 1B-DH-OF
152 Jake Burger 7 1B-3B-DH
153 Nico Hoerner 7 2B
154 Alec Bohm 7 3B
155 Logan O’Hoppe 7 C
156 Kenley Jansen 7 RP
157 Spencer Arrighetti 7 SP
158 Kris Bubic 7 RP
159 Pete Fairbanks 7 RP
160 Nick Pivetta 7 SP
161 Tyler O’Neill 7 OF
162 Brandon Nimmo 7 OF
163 Ezequiel Tovar 7 SS
164 Anthony Volpe 7 SS
165 Carlos Correa 7 SS
166 Kevin Gausman 6 SP
167 Roki Sasaki 6 SP
168 Brandon Lowe 6 2B-DH
169 Jackson Holliday 6 2B-SS
170 Royce Lewis 6 3B-DH
171 Jose Alvarado 6 RP
172 Nathan Eovaldi 6 SP
173 Andres Gimenez 6 2B
174 Bryson Stott 6 2B
175 Paul Goldschmidt 5 1B
176 Luis Rengifo 5 2B-3B
177 Spencer Torkelson 5 1B
178 Ben Rice 5 1B-DH
179 Luis Arraez 5 1B-2B-DH
180 Nick Lodolo 5 SP
181 Ryan Pepiot 5 SP
182 Jesus Luzardo 5 SP
183 Cedric Mullins 5 OF
184 Chris Bassitt 5 SP
185 Taj Bradley 5 SP
186 Sean Murphy 5 C
187 Ivan Herrera 5 C
188 Jung Hoo Lee 5 OF
189 Jonathan India 5 2B-3B-OF
190 Jorge Soler 5 DH-OF
191 Justin Martinez 5 RP
192 Michael Toglia 4 1B
193 Yandy Diaz 4 1B-DH
194 Alec Burleson 4 1B-DH-OF
195 Heliot Ramos 4 OF
196 Austin Wells 4 C
197 David Bednar 4 RP
198 Jeremy Pena 4 SS
199 Zachary Neto 4 SS
200 Ceddanne Rafaela 4 OF-SS
201 Taylor Ward 4 OF
202 Masyn Winn 4 SS
203 MacKenzie Gore 4 SP
204 Victor Scott II 4 OF
205 Lars Nootbaar 4 OF
206 Kerry Carpenter 4 DH-OF
207 A.J. Puk 3 RP
208 Clay Holmes 3 RP
209 Ryan Pressly 3 RP
210 Michael Conforto 3 DH-OF
211 Lane Thomas 3 OF
212 Shane McClanahan 3 SP
213 Grayson Rodriguez 3 SP
214 Max Meyer 3 SP
215 Gavin Williams 3 SP
216 Zach Eflin 3 SP
217 Dustin May 3 SP
218 Bowden Francis 3 RP-SP
219 Byron Buxton 3 OF
220 Jackson Jobe 3 RP
221 Lucas Erceg 3 RP
222 Kyren Paris 3 2B
223 Tyler Fitzgerald 3 2B-SS
224 Trevor Story 3 SS
225 Nolan Arenado 3 3B
226 Cam Smith 3 3B-OF
227 Jordan Walker 3 OF
228 Colton Cowser 3 OF
229 Josh Jung 3 3B
230 Carlos Estevez 2 RP
231 Aroldis Chapman 2 RP
232 Luke Jackson 2 RP
233 Kyle Finnegan 2 RP
234 Jeffrey Springs 2 SP
235 Brandon Pfaadt 2 SP
236 Kyle Manzardo 2 DH
237 Jack Leiter 2 SP
238 Tyler Mahle 2 SP
239 Casey Mize 2 SP
240 Mitch Keller 2 SP
241 Tanner Houck 2 SP
242 J.J. Bleday 2 OF
243 Hunter Goodman 2 C-DH-OF
244 Tyler Stephenson 2 C
245 TJ Friedl 2 OF
246 Ronel Blanco 2 SP
247 Maikel Garcia 2 2B-3B-OF
248 Dennis Santana 2 RP
249 Gabriel Moreno 2 C
250 Michael Busch 2 1B

 

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Pocket
WhatsApp

Never miss any important news. Subscribe to our newsletter.