Let’s not sugarcoat it—Jaguars fans have been through enough draft déjà vu to know the difference between hype and real help. Day 2 of the 2025 NFL Draft was a chance to stop the cycle of “developmental guys” and actually bring in ballers. This year, the Jags came out swinging on day one by moving up to select two-way phenom, Travis Hunter.
However, the moves on Day 2 felt like a mixed bag of genius and head scratching—but at least they weren’t sleepwalking through it. General Manager James Gladstone was aggressive but strategic, making more trades on draft night that landed the Jaguars two 2026 third-round selections while dropping back in the third round this year, only to move back up to 89 to have back-to-back picks.
So, did Jacksonville finally make the kind of moves that win games, or are we gearing up for another year of “just wait until next season”? Time to break it all down, pick by pick.
Round 3, Pick 88 – Caleb Ransaw, CB, Tulane
Grade: C
This one’s… fine. Not a disaster, but not a pick that gets the blood pumping either. Ransaw has the size and athletic profile you want in a modern corner, and he’s got that Tulane grit—he’s not afraid to stick his nose in and hit somebody. But let’s be real: the instincts and consistency just aren’t there yet. He’s grabby in coverage, gets caught guessing, and doesn’t exactly scream “plug-and-play.”
The ceiling? Maybe he’s a solid nickel or depth piece if he develops. The floor? Special teams or practice squad purgatory. With other cornerbacks still on the board who looked more polished, this felt like a reach. The Jags clearly see something, but right now, it feels like another “we can coach him up” gamble. Fingers crossed that works out this time under a new regime.
Round 3, Pick 89 – Wyatt Milum, OL, West Virginia
Grade: B
The Jaguars weren’t playing it safe with this pick, and it’s a smart gamble. Milum has the size (6’6”, 313 pounds) and nastiness you want in an offensive lineman. He’s been a mainstay at left tackle for West Virginia, showing solid run-blocking skills and the kind of strength that lets him control defenders at the point of attack. The guy is a powerhouse in the run game and can sustain blocks with ease.
But here’s the rub: his footwork and arm length have raised some concerns, which is why most think his future might be at guard rather than tackle.
Still, this is a value pick. The Jags have needed help up front for years, and Milum gives them versatility. He’s got the tools to develop into a starter—whether it’s at tackle or guard—and if the Jaguars can clean up his footwork, this could look like a steal down the road. At worst, he’s a depth piece who can plug in anywhere along the line when needed.
At the end of the day, Day 2 of the 2025 NFL Draft was a mix of calculated risk and high upside for the Jaguars. They didn’t play it safe, but they didn’t swing wildly either. Each move had its question marks, but also its potential rewards—whether it’s a cornerback with tools to develop in Ransaw or an offensive lineman with the grit and power of Milum.
The Jaguars are clearly trying to build for the future, one pick at a time. Time will tell if these selections pay off, but for now, Jags fans have reason to be cautiously optimistic as the team continues to shape its identity. Day 3 is shaping up to be very intriguing.
Related: Bold or Bust: Grading the Jacksonville Jaguars Draft Selection of Travis Hunter
Let’s not sugarcoat it—Jaguars fans have been through enough draft déjà vu to know the difference between hype and real help. Day 2 of the 2025 NFL Draft was a chance to stop the cycle of “developmental guys” and actually bring in ballers. This year, the Jags came out swinging on day one by moving up to select two-way phenom, Travis Hunter.
However, the moves on Day 2 felt like a mixed bag of genius and head scratching—but at least they weren’t sleepwalking through it. General Manager James Gladstone was aggressive but strategic, making more trades on draft night that landed the Jaguars two 2026 third-round selections while dropping back in the third round this year, only to move back up to 89 to have back-to-back picks.
So, did Jacksonville finally make the kind of moves that win games, or are we gearing up for another year of “just wait until next season”? Time to break it all down, pick by pick.
Round 3, Pick 88 – Caleb Ransaw, CB, Tulane
Grade: C
This one’s… fine. Not a disaster, but not a pick that gets the blood pumping either. Ransaw has the size and athletic profile you want in a modern corner, and he’s got that Tulane grit—he’s not afraid to stick his nose in and hit somebody. But let’s be real: the instincts and consistency just aren’t there yet. He’s grabby in coverage, gets caught guessing, and doesn’t exactly scream “plug-and-play.”
The ceiling? Maybe he’s a solid nickel or depth piece if he develops. The floor? Special teams or practice squad purgatory. With other cornerbacks still on the board who looked more polished, this felt like a reach. The Jags clearly see something, but right now, it feels like another “we can coach him up” gamble. Fingers crossed that works out this time under a new regime.
Round 3, Pick 89 – Wyatt Milum, OL, West Virginia
Grade: B
The Jaguars weren’t playing it safe with this pick, and it’s a smart gamble. Milum has the size (6’6”, 313 pounds) and nastiness you want in an offensive lineman. He’s been a mainstay at left tackle for West Virginia, showing solid run-blocking skills and the kind of strength that lets him control defenders at the point of attack. The guy is a powerhouse in the run game and can sustain blocks with ease.
But here’s the rub: his footwork and arm length have raised some concerns, which is why most think his future might be at guard rather than tackle.
Still, this is a value pick. The Jags have needed help up front for years, and Milum gives them versatility. He’s got the tools to develop into a starter—whether it’s at tackle or guard—and if the Jaguars can clean up his footwork, this could look like a steal down the road. At worst, he’s a depth piece who can plug in anywhere along the line when needed.
At the end of the day, Day 2 of the 2025 NFL Draft was a mix of calculated risk and high upside for the Jaguars. They didn’t play it safe, but they didn’t swing wildly either. Each move had its question marks, but also its potential rewards—whether it’s a cornerback with tools to develop in Ransaw or an offensive lineman with the grit and power of Milum.
The Jaguars are clearly trying to build for the future, one pick at a time. Time will tell if these selections pay off, but for now, Jags fans have reason to be cautiously optimistic as the team continues to shape its identity. Day 3 is shaping up to be very intriguing.
Related: Bold or Bust: Grading the Jacksonville Jaguars Draft Selection of Travis Hunter
